ElectroQuell Logo

November 11, 2026 · Backup Power · 13 min read

Diesel, Gas or Hybrid: Which backup power solution should you choose?

By Daniel Voss

Agregat Pradotworczy Urzad Gminy

Friday, 4:50 pm. Helen, facilities officer at a town council, is already zipping up her laptop bag when the mayor appears in the doorway with the question that somehow only ever gets asked on a Friday afternoon: “So what happens here if the power goes out?” The building houses the council offices, a server room and a community health clinic with vaccine fridges, and on Helen’s desk sit three quotes: diesel, gas and hybrid. Each sales rep is sure theirs is the right one. We will walk through the choice with Helen step by step, so that by the end you know which backup power to choose for a business or a public building, and what to ask your supplier.

In short: diesel, gas or hybrid?

For most businesses and public buildings, the simplest and most dependable backup power is a diesel generator with automatic mains failure (AMF) control: the fuel is stored on site and the generator typically picks up the load within 10 to 15 seconds. A gas generator makes sense where there is a reliable gas connection, where noise and exhaust matter, and ideally where the heat can be used too. A hybrid, meaning a generator combined with battery storage (often with solar PV as well), is the right tool when the site cannot accept even a few seconds of interruption, or when it draws very little power for many hours at a time.

Where do you start when choosing backup power?

Not with the fuel. Helen also started with “which generator?”, but the useful question is: what exactly has to keep running when the lights go out, and for how long?

In a council building, not everything needs power. The office coffee machine will survive an outage (the office itself may struggle, but that is a different story). The vaccine fridges, the server room, the boiler room and the escape route lighting will not.

Three numbers to have ready before you talk to a supplier:

  1. Priority load in kW: the things that genuinely have to run.
  2. Acceptable interruption: are 10 to 15 seconds of darkness a problem, or just a moment of “oh, it’s gone off”?
  3. Autonomy: how many hours the site must run without the grid and without a fuel delivery.

Once you have those three numbers, diesel, gas and hybrid stop being a matter of taste.

How much power does the site need? A worked example

Helen walked the building with an electrician and listed the priority loads:

  • server room and network: 5 kW,
  • LED lighting (including escape routes): 6 kW,
  • boiler room and circulation pumps: 6 kW,
  • clinic (medical fridges, consulting room equipment): 5 kW,
  • lift: 7 kW,
  • public service desks: 7 kW.

That makes 36 kW. Now three steps you can repeat for your own site.

Step 1. Headroom. A generator does not enjoy running flat out, and buildings have a habit of growing. Add 25%: 36 kW × 1.25 = 45 kW.

Step 2. From kW to kVA. Generators are rated in kVA, which is apparent power. At a typical power factor of 0.8 the rule is simple: 1 kVA equals about 0.8 kW of real power. So divide: 45 kW ÷ 0.8 ≈ 56 kVA.

Step 3. Motor starting. Lifts and pumps briefly draw several times their running current when they start. Rather than buying a generator twice the size “just in case”, you set a starting sequence: server room and lighting first, then the boiler room, the lift last.

The result: Helen is looking for a generator with a standby rating of around 60 to 66 kVA. At 66 kVA (52.8 kW), her 36 kW is about 68% load, so the generator works in a comfortable range and has room for motor starts. If your site cannot afford any gap at all and you are considering two units, we have a separate guide to generator sizing and redundancy mistakes to avoid.

One note on the nameplate: the standby rating (ESP) is the power available for the duration of a mains failure, while the prime rating (PRP) is for running as the main source of supply. For backup power you compare standby ratings, and always the same rating across every quote.

Diesel, gas or hybrid: how do they differ in practice?

We have the power figure. Here are the three quotes from Helen’s desk, set against the same criteria.

Criterion Diesel Gas Hybrid
Fuel source on-site tank gas grid or LPG tank battery storage + generator fuel
Load pick-up typically 10–15 s usually longer, in smaller steps battery instantly, generator in the background
Noise and exhaust on site highest of the three lower lowest while the battery is supplying
What it needs space, a tank, fuel rotation a connection with enough capacity inverter, controls, space for batteries
Upfront cost lowest higher (gas installation) highest
Strongest point independence and simplicity long running without fuel deliveries no interruption, few engine hours

What the table tells Helen: none of the quotes is a bad one, but each answers a different question. Diesel answers “will it work no matter what?”, gas answers “can it run for a long time, and more quietly?”, and hybrid answers “can we have no interruption at all?”.

When is a diesel generator the best choice?

When certainty and independence matter most. The diesel sits in a tank next to the generator, so operation does not depend on any network. AMF control with an automatic transfer switch detects the mains failure, starts the engine and switches the supply over by itself. Nobody has to run to the plant room with a torch between their teeth.

Diesel also copes well with sudden load steps, which is exactly what lifts, pumps and compressors produce. That makes it the first candidate for production plants, cold stores, water treatment works and anywhere the gas network is far away.

Two honest weak points. First, fuel ages, so the tank needs rotation or periodic quality checks. Second, a generator that runs for five minutes a month with no load has not been tested, only warmed up. Test runs should be done under real load.

When does a gas generator make more sense than diesel?

Gas wins in three situations: the site is in a dense urban area where noise and exhaust matter, the gas connection is reliable and has spare capacity, and the generator is expected to run for long periods or regularly, not only during outages.

The strongest argument appears when you can use the heat. A gas unit running as combined heat and power (CHP) produces electricity and useful heat at the same time, so for a swimming pool, a hospital or a plant with year-round heat demand it stops being a “rainy day” generator and starts earning its keep every day. There is more on these systems on our CHP solutions page.

Worth remembering: the gas grid usually keeps working through a local power cut, but it is outside your control. If the requirements for your site call for fuel stored on the premises, grid gas alone will not meet them. Before deciding, check with the network operator what pressure and flow the connection can deliver at the generator’s full demand.

When does a hybrid, a generator with battery storage, make sense?

A hybrid is not a third fuel, it is a team: the battery takes over the supply instantly, and the generator (diesel or gas) cuts in when the outage lasts longer. If there is solar PV on the roof, it chips in during the day.

There are two cases where this pays off. One: the site cannot tolerate even 10 to 15 seconds of interruption and a standard UPS is no longer enough. Two: the load is low for many hours. At night, Helen’s building runs only the server room, the fridges and the boiler room, about 8 kW in total. For a 66 kVA generator that is around 15% load, and a diesel engine at such a low load runs inefficiently and fouls up faster.

In a hybrid, the battery carries the 8 kW overnight, while the generator starts every few hours, runs at a healthy load, recharges the battery and goes quiet again. Fewer engine hours, less fuel, less noise for the neighbours. Exactly how much depends on the load profile and the battery size, so the numbers are worth working out for the specific site. We show what such a system looks like from the inside in our article on the real benefits of hybrid generators.

The catch: a battery that is too small is an expensive ornament, and one that is too large is hard to justify in a budget. A hybrid needs a well-designed control scheme, not just a battery purchase.

How much fuel do you need for 24 and 72 hours?

Autonomy is where diesel and gas differ the most. We calculate for Helen’s 36 kW. These are approximate values, based on typical consumption for generators of this size (about 0.27 litres of diesel or about 0.33 m³ of natural gas per kWh); always take exact figures from the data sheet of the specific model.

At 36 kW load Diesel Natural gas
Consumption per hour approx. 10 l approx. 12 m³
For 24 hours approx. 240 l approx. 290 m³
For 72 hours approx. 720 l approx. 860 m³
Where the fuel is tank on site gas grid

The takeaway for Helen: a day on diesel is about 240 litres, which a tank next to the generator can handle. Three days is over 700 litres, which brings in an additional tank, a fuel delivery agreement and local fuel storage rules that are worth checking for your location. Gas needs no tank, but all of its autonomy depends on the grid.

What does a generator for a site like this look like in practice?

Helen calculated about 56 kVA and wants a unit with headroom for motor starts. In our range, this model is one example that fits:

Example from our range

EQ-I6660 Iveco 66 kVA / 52.8 kW

With 36 kW of priority load it runs at about 68% of its standby rating, leaving headroom for starting the lift and the pumps.

Power 66 kVA / 52.8 kW (standby) · 60 kVA / 48 kW (prime)
Engine Iveco
Alternator Leroy-Somer
Control module ComAp
Price €13,159.50 net, excl. VAT, plus delivery · as of November 2026
View details Configure your own generator

Which mistakes do we see most often?

  • Sizing by adding up nameplates. The sum of rated powers says nothing about motor starting. This is where generators come from that “have the power” but cannot get the lift moving.
  • Backing up everything. A generator sized for the whole building is often twice as large as it needs to be. Separating out the priority circuits gives you the cheapest kilowatts in the whole project.
  • Gas without a call to the network operator. Having a connection does not mean the grid can deliver what the generator needs at full load.
  • A hybrid with a battery sized by eye. Without a load profile, battery capacity cannot be chosen properly.
  • Dry-run tests. A test with no load checks the starter motor, not the backup power system.

Public buildings: how do you describe backup power in a tender?

Helen still has to write the tender specification. In our experience, what works best is describing the function, not the technology: priority load, required autonomy in hours, maximum time to pick up the load, noise level at the installation point, scope of the AMF and transfer switch controls, acceptance tests under load and service terms.

A specification like this lets diesel, gas and hybrid be compared fairly in one procedure, because every bidder answers the same questions. The formal details depend on your procurement rules and the contract value, so check them with whoever runs the procedure.

Decision tool: diesel, gas or hybrid?

A table to take to the meeting with your supplier, your designer or your mayor.

If… consider and check
independence and a simple system matter most diesel with AMF tank, fuel rotation, tests under load
the site runs large motors diesel, possibly with a battery the load starting sequence
dense urban area, reliable gas connection a gas generator pressure and flow with the operator
you need heat all year round gas CHP the heat demand profile
not even seconds of interruption are acceptable a hybrid, or a generator with a UPS battery backup time
night-time load drops to 10–20% a hybrid battery capacity against the load profile

If two rows fit you at once, that is normal. Autonomy and budget usually settle it.

FAQ: common questions about backup power

Which is better for backup power: a diesel or a gas generator?

For typical backup power a diesel generator is chosen more often, because its fuel is on site and it picks up load quickly. A gas generator is the better option when the site has a reliable gas connection, needs quieter operation and lower local emissions, or uses the heat from CHP.

Can a hybrid system replace a generator?

For short outages yes, for long ones no. Battery storage will hold the supply for minutes or hours, depending on its capacity, and an outage lasting many hours needs a fuelled source. That is why a hybrid usually means a battery and a generator together.

How long does a generator take to pick up the supply?

A diesel generator with AMF control typically picks up the load within 10 to 15 seconds of a mains failure. If equipment cannot have any interruption, a UPS or battery storage bridges that time.

How do you convert kW to kVA when sizing a generator?

Divide the power in kW by the power factor. At a power factor of 0.8, a 45 kW load needs a generator of about 56 kVA. The other way round: 1 kVA is about 0.8 kW.

How much fuel does a diesel generator use during an outage?

As a rough guide, about 0.27 litres of diesel for every kWh produced. At a 36 kW load that is about 10 litres an hour and about 240 litres a day. The exact figure is in the model’s data sheet.

Does a public building have to back up the whole site?

Usually not. In most cases it is enough to supply the priority circuits: safety systems, emergency lighting, the server room, the boiler room and equipment whose shutdown causes losses. Confirm the scope required for your specific building with your designer.

How did Helen’s story end?

On Monday the mayor received a single page: 36 kW of priority load, a diesel generator of about 66 kVA with AMF control, a tank for one day of running and a fuel delivery agreement for longer outages. The few seconds of interruption in the server room are covered by the UPS the council already owns. Helen put the hybrid down as phase two, together with the solar PV planned for the roof, because 8 kW overnight is just the right job for battery storage. The mayor read it, nodded, and asked only why they had not done this sooner. That is also a question that always gets asked.

If you have a list of equipment and would rather not do the sums yourself, send it to us. In a free 15-minute consultation we will tell you what power and which option make sense for your site, including when the answer is “smaller than you think”.

Thank you for following this comparison with us and with Helen, from the mayor’s Friday question to the Monday one-pager. If you would like to see what those calculated kilowatts look like in real life, have a look at the full range of ElectroQuell generators. And on our LinkedIn page we share projects and a look behind the scenes at the team that builds them. Come and say hello.

  • diesel generator
  • gas generator
  • hybrid power system
  • generator sizing

Related Articles

View all

15 minutes with a specialist. Free.

Tell us your load, site and timeline. We recommend the right unit and handle the technical details.

+49 176 82370794